Reviewing Wolf and Shepherd (2022): After More than a Year of Use, See Why These Dress Shoes Remain the Ultimate Combination of Style and Comfort

This post may contain affiliate links. Learn more.

Find out how Wolf and Shepherd’s Closer cap-toe lace-up oxfords performed after more than two years of heavy use in this updated review.

In search of stylish, comfortable dress shoes

Too often, spectacular-looking dress shoes sacrifice comfort for style, while the few comfort-focused brands out there leave a lot to be desired in the looks department.

Wolf and Shepherd, a Los-Angeles-based startup, began life as an effort to deliver gorgeous men’s dress shoes that are as comfortable as sneakers. Wolf and Shepherd quickly became one of my favorite innovative brands making the best men’s dress shoes online.

Wolf and Shepherd’s pivot to hybrid crossover dress shoes

This updated article builds upon my review of Wolf and Shepherd’s cap-toe oxfords and interview with founder Justin Schneider that I first published in May 2018.

Since then, Wolf and Shepherd has pivoted away from traditional dress shoes to focus heavily on their striking and unique Longwing hybrid dress shoes and their versatile Swiftknit Derby crossovers.

These comprise a new category of shoes that are great for pairing with stylish business casual outfits for men, but have left me in search of a new favorite option for comfortable dress shoes.

Read on for an overview of Wolf and Shepherd, my initial impressions of their comfortable dress shoes and additional thoughts on their durability after wearing them to and from work for more than a year.

Also check out my review of Wolf and Shepherd’s Bannister Derbies, which are another option for comfortable dress shoes for the new normal.

Sadly, Wolf and Shepherd pivoted so hard that they no longer make any true dress shoes anymore. See my review of Warfield and Grand to see why they are an excellent alternative to Wolf and Shepherd for stylish and comfortable dress shoes.

Wolf and Shepherd provided a pair of shoes at no cost for the purpose of this review.

Wolf and Shepherd Coupon: Save 20%

When I navigated to Wolf and Shepherd’s website, I was offered a pop up with a 20% discount coupon off of a Wolf and Shepherd purchase for signing up to emails.

About Wolf and Shepherd

In the summer of 2014, a friend called up Wolf and Shepherd founder Justin Schneider, pictured below, to say that his dress shoes were so uncomfortable that he had to take them off while sitting at his desk and wear sneakers to and from work to avoid having them on longer than he needed to. “This seemed to be a consistent problem among my peers,” Justin told Modern Fellows.

He started cutting up shoes and gluing sneaker insoles to dress shoe uppers. “By the end of that year, I had a working prototype of a classic dress shoe with an innovative foam sole,” Justin recalls. From there, he found a factory in Portugal, identified the suppliers, including a top-of-the-line Italian leather company, and developed a proprietary, patent-protected foam. The company launched a pre-sale campaign in July 2015 for their comfortable dress shoes and was off-and-running, adding new styles, refining its technology, and ramping up ever since.

The brand received a nice pop of media coverage after runner Juris Silenieks set a new world record by running the Hotlanta half marathon in Wolf and Shepherd’s dress shoes.

What’s So Special About Wolf and Shepherd’s Shoes

Having walked around the streets of Washington, DC for the better part of two months in the pair of cap-toe lace-up oxfords the company sent over, it’s clear that Wolf and Shepherd has nailed a near-perfect combination of good looks, comfort and craftsmanship.

In terms of comfort, while the shoes took about 3 wearings to break in and feel truly my own, since then, they have felt about as good as sneakers walking around the city. (Pro tip: Wear the shoes around the house or for a couple of quick outings to break them in.) I wore them to take Flat Stanley on a long adventure past the White House and Washington Monument, on an 11-hour day spent mostly on my feet at work, and while sloshing through an unusually long bout of rain in the DMV.

They’re lightweight — about a pound lighter than most other dress shoes, according to the company — and boast a bevvy of technologies in their multiple insole layers from high-density foam heel adapted from athletic shoes to carbon-fiber arch support and sheepskin lining in the upper-most layer.

All of that technology is housed in a pair of shoes that look professional and sleek with just a little bit of flair. The slight burnishing of the maple Italian calfskin on the toes (pictured above) is a nice touch, as is the tiny eyelet at the top of the laces (pictured below).

I received two compliments in two days on my shoes, including one from a stranger on K Street.

Structurally, the leather has held up well and hasn’t cracked or crumpled, as has happened to cheaper oxfords I’ve worn the past. (See below for a picture of what the shoes look like after 8 weeks of heavy use.) The shoes are not Goodyear welted but rather Blake welted and cemented. 

A nice feature is that the shoes’ forefoot and heel can be resoled, potentially extending the life and look of the shoes.

All of this comfort, style and technology comes at a price. Retailing for $345, Wolf and Shepherd’s oxfords might be best classified as “affordable luxury.” While they aren’t cheap, they are in line with traditional brands like Allen Edmonds.

One note: While I reviewed oxford lace-ups, Wolf and Shepherd offers a range of boots, loafers, driving shoes, Crossover Longwings and Swiftknit derbies as well. Given how comfortable the oxfords were, I’d be willing to bet that their suede Gunner Driver shoes would feel like putting on a pair of slippers.

Justin, who was named to the Forbes 30-under-30 list for retail and e-commerce in 2017, says the company’s focus and DNA have remained the same from Day One: “producing the most comfortable, stylish men’s dress shoes with premium quality and classic heritage.”

Reviewing the Durability of Wolf and Shepherd Shoes after One Year

As a consumer, it’s often hard to know what to make of product reviews that feature perfectly-glossy photos of just-unboxed gear. After weeks, months and years, clothes and shoes wear and colors fade, yet some products hold up better than others.

The pictures in this section depict the same cap-toe lace-up oxfords I reviewed in May 2018 after a year of wear.

These shoes have held up remarkably well to everything that I’ve thrown at them, from downpours in DC through to multiple-mile walks through muggy Manila.

Critically, they are still waterproof and the soles haven’t opened to the elements.

After more than a year of heavy use, these shoes have proven their value.

How Focusing on Customers Helps Wolf and Shepherd’s E-Commerce-Focused Brand

The company’s core business is direct to consumer e-commerce — though their shoes can also be found at select menswear stockists — so Wolf and Shepherd has to stand out online and find ways to give confidence to potential customers to make a significant purchase online.

For one, Wolf and Shepherd allows returns for a refund or exchange within 30 days of the shipping date, and domestic (U.S.) returns are free of charge.

Justin says that, “what we’ve learned most from our customers is to listen to them about what next steps we need to take as a company.”

We take their feedback very seriously. They guide our product decisions, let us know if our storytelling is resonating, help determine what markets we should nurture and get a foothold in, and communicate if we’re positively impacting their lives. Listening to them is paramount to our business.

What’s Next for Wolf and Shepherd 

What’s next for the startup brand? Justin told me back in 2018 that, “we’re currently in a growth phase, so the next year is critical as we look to scale and evolve.”

Since then, Wolf and Shepherd released the bold (and I think uniquely good-looking) Cross-over Longwing, a hybrid sneaker with a leather dress upper that they developed with basketball legend Steve Nash.

I had a chance to review the Longwing crossover by Wolf and Shepherd, which is distinctive and maybe not for everyone, but it’s definitely not boring.

Continue to look for new styles, new concepts and new categories.

For example, the company added soft driving shoes, traditional leather sneakers and belts to its online offerings, along with the Longwing Crossovers.

Wolf and Shepherd has also expandd its line of crossovers, debuting a wingtip hybrid dress shoe, a hybrid penny loafer and Crossover boots.

The company has further expanded its line of hybrids with a 3D-printed knit upper known as Swiftknit Derbies (pictured above). I particularly like the look of the Swiftknit, which is part of a new category of minimalist woven knit shoes and sneakers offered by brands like Allbirds and Vessi.

“Ultimately, we want to be more than a go-to shoe for men; we want to be a go-to brand for style, quality and performance,” he added.

Photo credit: Photo of Justin Schneider courtesy of Wolf and Shepherd.

About Jake

Jake is an expert on men’s style and fashion based in Washington, DC. He founded Modern Fellows in 2012 to get to know the entrepreneurs and innovative clothing and lifestyle brands helping men dress sharp in the digital age. He has published hundreds of articles on style and apparel, and regularly interviews small business CEOs and startup founders about industry trends. Jake has written about entrepreneurship, international business and fashion for outlets including Business Week, Forbes, Inc., Details Style Syndicate and Primer Magazine.

Other cool stuff:

* Get $25 off your first experience with Wantable, an amazing online personal styling option for men and women.
* Take 10% off your first order from Proper Cloth, one of my favorite online custom tailors.
* For comfortable Athleisure clothing for women and men, try these 25 alternatives to lululemon.
* Find 21 Alternatives to Warby Parker that also let you try on prescription eyeglasses at home.
* The Essential List: These 125 innovative menswear startup brands will transform your wardrobe
* Upgrade your business casual wardrobe with comfortable yet professional-looking workleisure clothing made from stretchy performance fabrics.
* Get $50 off your first suit at Black Lapel, one of my favorite online custom tailors.
* Discover the best places to buy colorful socks online.

11 thoughts on “Reviewing Wolf and Shepherd (2022): After More than a Year of Use, See Why These Dress Shoes Remain the Ultimate Combination of Style and Comfort”

  1. While I have three cross overs/swift knits and like them, I wish the company would still produce (ideally in conjunction with the new stuff) more of their old dress shoes. They were remarkably comfortable, high quality, and good looking.

  2. After a year of minimal wear they squeak terribly. Contacted their customer service only to hear not their problem. Do not recommend.

  3. I was given a fifty dollar gift card to Wolf & Shepherd by a colleague. Recently, I attempted to use it to purchase a pair of shoes that I saw. From the W&S main webpage, I clicked shop, then ‘Sale’ and it took me to what they call “Last Call”. This is all of their discounted items. I saw a pair of shoes for $100. Figured awesome I would use the gift card and part with an additional $50 bucks. I was denied. Told that it was their policy that store credit could not be used for sale items. I tried, without success, multiple times to explain this is not store credit but rather my attempt to use a gift card that was purchased for me with US currency. I do not believe they are allowed to do this, are they!?

  4. Hi David, thanks so much for the feedback! Please reach out to our customer experience team if you’d like some assistance making another selection you love. I assure you, we do not pay for reviews, as Jake mentioned! We do have a lot of happy customers, and would love for you to become one of them!

  5. My shoes broke after a year, leather separated from the sole. Very disappointed, poor quality to price. I like the look of them, but wont spend $350 on a pair of shoes lasting that short of a time.

  6. After 6 months of wear, the leather became separated from the sole on one of my shoes (about a 2-inch long area). I sent photos in to the company and they immediately offered to replace the shoes for free. Maybe I had a defective pair? Awaiting shipment of the new ones.

    As for the leather, it is very soft and supple – and maybe because of this, the leather seems to scratch / tear a lot easier than other full-grain leather dress shoes I’ve owned for years.

    On comfort, I would say they are average. I certainly would not be tempted to run a mile in these let alone a half-marathon as advertised. I think a brand new pair of Johnston Murphy trampoline soles might be a little more comfortable.

    I appreciate the rubber sole over a slippery leather one and, overall, the shoes are certainly very sharp looking. Possibly the only shoe I can find that looks like a nice dress shoe but has a rubber sole.

  7. Hi David, I can’t speak definitively to their customer service, but, as I noted in my review, my pair of shoes has held up well for more than a year. And to clarify, this is not a sponsored post or paid review, though I did receive a pair of shoes for free from the company.


Join the Conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.