Can an App Be Your Tailor? Reviewing MTailor Custom Dress Shirts

This post may contain affiliate links. Learn more.

tailor-tape-1Can an app take measurements as accurately as a tailor? New online startup MTailor delivers precision measurements via your iPhone.

When Miles Penn approached Modern Fellows to review a custom shirt from his recently-launched technology-meets-fashion concept MTailor, I was skeptical.

MTailor’s pitch? A custom shirt that removes the need to take your own measurements or visit a tailor.

Download an app, set it down on the floor 10 feet away from you, spin 360 degrees, and — voila — you’re measured and ready to start selecting details for your custom dress shirt.


MTailor claims that their app measurements are 20 percent more accurate than a professional tailor — a statistic they came to by bringing in 4 tailors to measure 35 people, asking those same 35 people to measure themselves using the MTailor app, and then comparing the results.

Really? Well — yes — really, as long as you don’t mind spinning around in your underwear.  The shirt that MTailor delivered fits as well as any made-to-measure product out there.

Inside MTailor

Miles dropped out of a Masters degree program in computer science at Stanford to found MTailor, whose app made it to the Apple store in mid-February in Beta, and which launched officially on June 28.

The business came out of his frustration about not being able to buy clothing he wanted to buy online. Having to measure yourself poses a unique fit problem when it comes to buying clothes online.

“We cut out the time consuming measurement process,” says Miles. “Me and my cofounder went through a year developing the technology. We are math and machine learning people.”

He also recognized that measurements are not the end of custom clothing.  “There are elements of style too,” observes Miles. “We worked with a well-known New York tailor to understand how to translate measurements into well-fitting shirts.”

MTailor uses data analysis to provide insight into when they get the styling right or wrong based on customer feedback, and has made tweaks along the way.


Reviewing the MTailor experience

The MTailor website is sparse, serving mostly to drive customers to download its app, where the magic happens.

Its app is fairly intuitive, and the photos of the fabrics are decent if not spectacular.

Mtailor first prompts a customer to select a fabric.  There are a nice variety of fabrics – including a wild blue paisley and a wintry blue and brown flannel cotton — which can be sorted by “dress, all-purpose or casual,” though it would be nice to have some additional options (for example to sort by color).

Next, customers select from a limited set of collars — wide spread, straight point, regular button down and a softer casual button down. (Here too, it would be useful to have more information on the length of the collar points and spread of the collars.)


From there it is time to get measured up.  Start by watching a 50 second instructional video, which walks customers through how to place an iPhone down on the floor at a certain angle, stand back and turn in a circle.  You need to go shirtless or wear a spandex undershirt and briefs or boxers. (I wore a Ribbed-T undershirt, which worked fine.)

It’s an unusual experience, and it’ll be interesting to see how many guys are willing to give it a shot.

Miles suggested that “some people are concerned about getting measured in their underwear,” though said he thinks that “the barrier is actually lower than someone sending you a tape measure and asking you to do it yourself. The level of convenience is so much higher. If you want to order a custom shirt from us, within 5 minutes, you can place an order.”

He also noted that, after MTailor reviews your video, it is permanently deleted.


While the app works well, it would be nice to be able do more via the website — enter shipping information, peruse fabrics and collar options, etc.  The small screen doesn’t do the fabrics justice, and my fingers managed to key in an incorrect address when I entered my shipping information via my iPhone.

As for the shirt itself? It fits like you would expect a custom-tailored shirt to fit. It’s slim but not tight. The sleeves sit right above my thumb; armholes are higher than off the rack shirts; and the collar frames my face nicely.  It’s a well-fitting shirt throughout, all without me having to take any measurements.  It’s an impressive feat.

The shirts are made in China by a manufacturer with whom MTailor works closely.  MTailor selects a rotating range of fabrics — also sourced from China — and stocks everything from 50’s and 60’s to 140 thread count.

The for my shirt — a light blue gingham that sells for $69 — isn’t Thomas Mason — but at that price point is a great choice for an everyday shirt.


Customer service, alterations policy, and reorders

MTailor offers free shipping, and no tax. They pledge to get orders shipped to your door n approximately 3 weeks. It took a little less than that — 2 1/2 weeks — for my shirt to arrive.

The company offers a generous return policy — what they call “risk-free shopping.” They offer free remakes “if anything isn’t perfect,” and free returns, “no questions asked free refunds, even on a remake. No return shipping fee.”

Several days after my shirt arrived, I received a note from an employee at MTailor flagging that I should have received my shirt, and that he’d “love to know what [I] think. Remember,” he went on, “if there is anything you’d like to change, we’ll remake your shirt for free or give you your money back. Or, if you prefer, we can make a note for next time.” A month later, I received another email, asking how I liked my shirt a month into receiving it.

Nice touches.



MTailor challenges the notion that tailoring is one of the few professions exempt from competition from machines.  If you can get past the strangeness of spinning in front of your iPhone in your underwear, MTailor is an outstanding choice for a solid and relatively inexpensive everyday shirt.

Miles notes that, “we’re working on expanding the product line,” and hopes to move into suits in the next year or so.

Photo credits: Featured photo (tape measure) courtesy of Ciara McDonnell / workshoppe via Flickr

About Jake

Jake is an expert on men’s style and fashion based in Washington, DC. He founded Modern Fellows in 2012 to get to know the entrepreneurs and innovative clothing and lifestyle brands helping men dress sharp in the digital age. He has published hundreds of articles on style and apparel, and regularly interviews small business CEOs and startup founders about industry trends. Jake has written about entrepreneurship, international business and fashion for outlets including Business Week, Forbes, Inc., Details Style Syndicate and Primer Magazine.

Other cool stuff:

* Get $25 off your first experience with Wantable, an amazing online personal styling option for men and women.
* Take 10% off your first order from Proper Cloth, one of my favorite online custom tailors.
* For comfortable Athleisure clothing for women and men, try these 25 alternatives to lululemon.
* Find 21 Alternatives to Warby Parker that also let you try on prescription eyeglasses at home.
* The Essential List: These 125 innovative menswear startup brands will transform your wardrobe
* Upgrade your business casual wardrobe with comfortable yet professional-looking workleisure clothing made from stretchy performance fabrics.
* Get $50 off your first suit at Black Lapel, one of my favorite online custom tailors.
* Discover the best places to buy colorful socks online.

7 thoughts on “Can an App Be Your Tailor? Reviewing MTailor Custom Dress Shirts”

  1. I purchased a shirt on MTaylor and USPS lost my package, after 2 months still haven’t received it yet. I opened case on USPS to have the package but didn’t have success. I see other comments of delayed deliveries. There is no way to contact MTaylor to complain. I’m afraid to say MTaylor is not trustworthy

  2. Just received my shirt today. Fit was great. Material was not the same as a Brooks Brothers bespoke but still very nice for a daily wearer at a fraction of the cost. Will be getting a few more.

  3. I decided to try it and ordered a shirt. Haven’t received it yet. Shipping has been delayed twice. Not an issue as long as the shirt really fits. I am a short stocky guy and off the rack rarely fits.

  4. My husband is 6’5″ and has extra long arms with a lean build. Finding him shirts that fit is near impossible. I saw a commercial for M Tailor and had to try it. We get his shirt this week, and I’ll be reviewing. Fingers crossed! Glad to see you had a good experience!

  5. This is a fantastic service! As someone with an athletic build, it’s always been difficult to find a shirt that fits in the shoulders without billowing out in the waist. I’ve ordered 2 shirts from M.Tailor and have been extremely pleased with the results. Their selections of patterns and fibers continues to expand, and I will continue to turn over my existing wardrobe with their products.

    Now if they could only do something with pants….

  6. Not near enough selection of colors to choose from. I only like 100% cotton material because I like heavy starch shirts.
    Did not see cotton material in your fabric selection. Wilton Decuir


Join the Conversation

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.